← All writing

Consciousness

What If Consciousness Is Fundamental?

Most of us were taught that matter comes first and mind comes later. Some serious thinkers suspect it might be the other way around.

The default view in modern science is that the universe is made of matter and energy, and that consciousness appeared late, when matter got organized into brains complex enough to produce it. Mind is something the brain does.

That view has been extraordinarily productive. It has also left one question stubbornly open. How does physical stuff produce the feeling of experience at all?

That gap has led some philosophers and scientists to consider a different starting point.

Three broad positions

Materialism, or physicalism. Everything is physical. Consciousness is produced by, or identical to, brain processes. The hard problem will eventually be solved or dissolved by better science.

Panpsychism. Some form of experience is a basic feature of matter itself, present in a very simple form everywhere, and combined into rich experience in complex systems like brains.

Idealism. Consciousness is the fundamental reality, and what we call matter is how experience appears from a certain point of view.

Each of these has serious defenders. Each has real problems. Materialism has trouble explaining why experience exists at all. Panpsychism has trouble explaining how tiny experiences combine into a single mind. Idealism has trouble explaining why the physical world is so stable and lawlike.

Where I lean, and why

My own experiences push me toward the view that consciousness is more basic than the brain. Moments where nearly everything was stripped away and awareness remained. A run of experiences over about eighteen months, which I describe in The Road to Ronda, that I cannot explain and have never been able to dismiss as coincidence.

But I want to be very clear. Personal experience is not proof. It is a reason I find these questions urgent, not a reason anyone else should accept my conclusion.

What would change if it were true

If consciousness were fundamental, it would change how we think about death, about our connection to each other, and about what it means for anything, including machines, to have experience. It would not change the physics. It would change what the physics is a description of.

Holding the question open

I think the honest position right now is that nobody knows. The best response to not knowing is not to pick a team and defend it. It is to keep looking, keep testing ideas against experience and evidence, and stay curious.

That is what I intend to keep doing here.

consciousnessphilosophyidealismpanpsychismmaterialismExplorations of Consciousness
Jaime Boyaca

Technology executive, speaker and explorer of consciousness. This idea is also the heart of his keynote From Reaction to Response.